When EMDR Doesn't Work: Exploring Alternatives and Next Steps
Two men engaged in conversation, one in a suit sitting on a couch, the other seated on a chair with a notepad.
Understanding EMDR Therapy
EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing) is a comprehensive psychotherapy that helps individuals process and recover from past experiences that are affecting their mental health and wellbeing. It involves the use of side-to-side eye movements combined with talk therapy in a specific and structured format. EMDR helps individuals process the negative images, emotions, beliefs, and body sensations associated with traumatic memories that seem to be stuck, often leading to a range of mental health problems. By engaging in EMDR therapy, individuals can gain a different perspective and find relief from the symptoms they were experiencing. With the guidance of a therapist trained in EMDR, individuals can kickstart their natural healing and recovery process after trauma, with the therapist walking alongside them throughout their healing journey.
What can EMDR help with?
While EMDR is best known for its effectiveness in treating trauma or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), it can also be used to help with a range of mental health difficulties. These include anxiety, depression, addictions, behavioral difficulties, relationship issues, as well as more serious mental illnesses such as psychosis and personality disorders. It is important to note that many of these problems may actually be rooted in some kind of trauma, whether experienced during childhood or as an adult, and it may not always be obvious that trauma is the underlying cause. EMDR therapy can help identify and address these hidden traumas, offering individuals the opportunity to heal from within.
How does EMDR work?
EMDR follows a specific structure, and therapists typically guide individuals through several stages of therapy. The initial stages involve assessing the individual's current symptoms and readiness for EMDR therapy, as well as understanding how their past experiences have shaped their present. The therapist also explains why the individual is experiencing their current symptoms and how trauma affects the mind, making it feel like it will never go away. By understanding the root causes of their distress, individuals can begin to prepare for the processing of traumatic memories.
The next part of the therapy involves accessing the traumatic memories and initiating bilateral stimulation. Bilateral stimulation refers to stimulating either side of the brain in an alternating left-right fashion. This can be achieved through eye movements, sounds played through headphones, or tapping on different sides of the body. The eye movements used in EMDR therapy may be similar to rapid eye movement (REM) sleep that occurs during dreaming. By engaging in bilateral stimulation, individuals can access their subconscious mind and process the stored traumatic memories, gaining a new perspective on how these memories affect them.
Throughout the therapy process, the therapist helps individuals kickstart their natural healing process by replacing negative or traumatic images and memories with more positive and empowering ones. This shift in perspective occurs from within the individual and brings about transformative changes that feel true at a gut level. Some individuals may experience remarkable changes in how they feel, transitioning from feelings of terror or shame to calmness and empowerment. While some individuals may find relief from their symptoms after just a few sessions of EMDR therapy, others with more complex issues may require additional sessions for the therapy to make a substantial difference.
Exploring EMDR Effectiveness
EMDR therapy has been extensively researched and proven to be an effective psychotherapy method for helping individuals recover from trauma and PTSD symptoms. Ongoing research continues to support positive clinical outcomes associated with EMDR therapy, demonstrating its efficacy in treating various disorders such as anxiety, depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), chronic pain, addictions, and other distressing life experiences.
Multiple national and international organizations, including the American Psychiatric Association, American Psychological Association, and the World Health Organization, recognize EMDR therapy as an effective treatment. It has received recognition from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) in the UK and is endorsed by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. The effectiveness of EMDR therapy has been compared to other treatments, with some studies even demonstrating its superiority to conventional treatments such as medication.
Seeking Alternatives to EMDR
While EMDR therapy has shown significant effectiveness for many individuals, it is important to recognize that it may not be suitable for everyone or every situation. There can be several reasons why EMDR may not work effectively for certain individuals, including the presence of severe dissociation, significant ongoing stressors, or a lack of readiness to engage in the therapeutic process. In such cases, it is crucial to identify alternative therapies that may better meet the individual's needs.
Several alternative therapies exist for individuals who do not find EMDR therapy effective. These include cognitive-behavioral therapy, psychodynamic therapy, somatic experiencing, and art therapy, among others. The choice of alternative therapy will depend on the individual's specific needs, preferences, and the recommendation of their therapist or mental health professional. It is important to remember that what works for one person may not necessarily work for another, so a personalized approach is crucial in finding the most effective treatment option.
It is also important to acknowledge the limitations of EMDR therapy. While it has shown effectiveness in treating various conditions, it may not be a standalone solution for all individuals. Some individuals may require a combination of therapies or ongoing support to maintain their mental health.
Additionally, it is important to consider that EMDR therapy may not completely erase traumatic memories, but rather help individuals process and reframe them in a way that is less distressing.
Therefore, additional support and coping strategies may be necessary for individuals to navigate their ongoing healing journey.
Next Steps After EMDR
After completing EMDR therapy, individuals may choose to explore alternative treatments or engage in follow-up care to maintain their mental health and well-being. Transitioning to alternative treatments, such as those mentioned earlier, can provide individuals with additional tools and strategies to continue their healing process. These treatments often focus on addressing specific symptoms or underlying issues that may not have been fully resolved through EMDR therapy alone.
Engaging in follow-up care is crucial for individuals who have completed EMDR therapy. This may involve regular check-ins with a therapist or mental health professional to monitor progress, address any emerging concerns, and provide ongoing support. Follow-up care can help individuals navigate any challenges that may arise after completing EMDR therapy and ensure that they continue to receive the support they need to maintain their mental well-being.
FAQs
What are common reasons why EMDR may not work?
EMDR therapy may not be effective for everyone, and there can be various reasons for this. Some common reasons why EMDR may not work effectively for certain individuals include severe dissociation, ongoing stressors that interfere with the therapeutic process, a lack of readiness or commitment to engaging in therapy, or incomplete processing of traumatic memories. It is important to discuss any concerns or challenges with a therapist or mental health professional to explore alternative therapies or approaches.
Are there alternative treatments to consider if EMDR does not work?
Yes, there are several alternative treatments that individuals can consider if EMDR therapy does not work effectively for them. These include cognitive-behavioral therapy, psychodynamic therapy, somatic experiencing, art therapy, and others. The choice of an alternative treatment will depend on the individual's specific needs and the recommendation of their therapist or mental health professional.
How long does it typically take for EMDR to show results, and what if it doesn't work within that time frame?
The length of time it takes for EMDR therapy to show results can vary depending on the individual and the nature of their experiences. Some individuals may experience significant improvements after just a few sessions, while others may require more sessions to achieve the desired outcomes. If EMDR therapy does not seem to be working within a reasonable time frame, it may be necessary to discuss this with the therapist or mental health professional and explore alternative treatments or approaches.
What should individuals do if they have tried EMDR without success?
If individuals have tried EMDR therapy without success, it is important to address this with their therapist or mental health professional. They can discuss alternative treatment options or approaches that may be better suited to their needs. It is crucial not to lose hope and to remember that different therapies work for different individuals. With the support and guidance of a qualified professional, it is possible to find an alternative treatment that can help individuals on their healing journey.
